Black Sheep Cream

Reviews

• Amber T.

  star star star star star 19 July 2026

  The BEST ice cream I've had! There were several flavors to choose from and they all sounded amazing so it was hard to choose. I ended up getting one scoop of their strawberries and cream in a waffle cone. Let me say that their waffle cones are like none other! They're crisp and thin with a hint of cinnamon on them. Amazing! One scoop was a pretty good portion where I felt very satisfied after. Friends I was with ordered flavors with macadamia nuts and there were whole nuts in it! So macadamia nut lovers, that is perfect for you. And their cookie dough chunks are huge also!
  
  The staff was very friendly and let us have samples of flavors. I will need to go back very soon!

• Callie D.

  star star star star star 17 July 2026

  Made the drive up here on friends recommendation and no regrets here!  The flavors are creative and look like they change constantly, and the textures for the most oart are deliciously creamy. The only texture issue I had was the strawberries were icy and affected the texture of the peanut butter ice cream around it too. Can't decide on a flavor?  Get a flight of 4 kid-sized scoops with a bowl of either caramel or fudge sauce to share. Our favorite was the black sesame flavor - strong, oddly satisfying in its savory edge. The matcha was the most mellow green tea ice cream I've had, but it paired well with the black sesame. We tried the Sugar Daddy - brown sugar vanilla with cookie dough - which paired nicely with the fudge. I would have liked the fudge to be thicker, but the flavor was good. The last in our flight was the aforementioned peanut butter and strawberry that had good flavor if too icy a texture.
  
  They have disposable plastic cups for free water, which surprised me a little as the overall vibe of the place hints at sustainable with actual ceramic bowls for the ice cream and real silverware spoons. Ok seating for small groups but could get crowded fast.

• R Andrew D.

  star star star star star 8 July 2026

  Oh wow!
  Where to start.....
  First things first... IT'S TOTALLY WORTH THE DRIVE!
  Totally original flavors (see photos)... and very reasonably priced. My wife and I shared a "flight"... 4 flavors and a Center sauce (hot fudge)... it was delivered quickly and with recommendations on pairing the amazingly original flavors to create even more unique flavors. Where their "Matcha" flavor was a little milder than some, their "Black roasted sesame" made up for in intense deliciousness!
  
  Make the trip! You'll thank yourself!

• Michael W.

  star star star star star 3 July 2026

  This place is a bit out of the way if you live in town, but it is worth it! Blacksheep is located in north Waipahu area and it looks kinda dark if you come around at night, but waiting is some pretty awesome icecream! They let you sample all the flavors you want and they are very nice about it. I really enjoyed the service I got here.
  
  For the flavors, they have some pretty unique ones and some a bit more common. We got the sampler (highly recommend) to try many flavors if you have 2-4 people to share it with. We had two chocolate ones, unicorn poop, and the kookie cookie. The ice cream overall was smooth, creamy, and the flavors were true to the description. My favorite was the kookie cookie. It tastes like cookie butter ice cream. If you love ice cream, come give this place a try!

• Karen D.

  star star star star star_border 25 June 2026

  One of my favorite ice cream eateries. Love the different flavors with unique names. My favorite is Mojo Jojo which is a coffee flavored ice cream with wonderful brittle bits in it